Who Wore it Better? Monica vs. Alicia Keys vs. Mel B in Stella McCartney’s Evening 2012 Colorblock Dress

Mel B was spied headed to “X Factor” auditions in Manchester, England earlier today sporting the same $795 Stella McCartney black and white colorblock Evening 2012 dress worn by Alicia Keys and Monica.

While all three ladies opted for black heels, with Mel in Versace, Alicia in Stella McCartney, and Monica in Giuseppe Zanotti, Monica was the only celeb to break up the monotone white and black with a bright green Birkin bag.
The two-tone dress features a form-fitting, knee-length silhouette, and sleeves that measure right above the elbow.

Alicia won the last Who Wore it Better in a landslide, I love how Monica added a bit of color with her bag. And as for Mel B, those shoes seems way to chunky for such a sleek look. What do you think?

*Can’t decide? Get the dress, plus versions of each of their heels here:

Images: Zimbio


Claire Sulmers is the publisher and founder of Fashion Bomb Daily, the #43 most influential style blog in the world.